A Katrina update and place to comment

Update [2005-8-28 16:26:45 by Prof. Goose]:Here's a link to a really good map of oil refining/SPR storage facilities in respect to the current path of Katrina.

Update [2005-8-28 16:28:27 by Prof. Goose]:And then, below the fold, there's an important comment from Stratfor by DanteA at the bottom of ProfG's earlier post and a picture of Katrina in infrared, and a link and snippets from an article from NOLA.com about the "BIG ONE" that was written a while back. Just like The Oil Storm, this is scary too.

This was sent to me from Stratfor at 3:08pm EST today

 Summary: hypothesis of a "worst case" scenario of the effects of Hurr. Kat. on the Port of New Orleans/So. La. (from which 15% of all U.S. exports pass- as measured by value)

The Geopolitics of Katrina

 A Category 5 hurricane, the most severe type measured, Katrina has been reported heading directly toward the city of New Orleans. This would be a human catastrophe, since New Orleans sits in a bowl below sea level. However, Katrina is not only moving on New Orleans. It also is moving on the Port of Southern Louisiana. Were it to strike directly and furiously, Katrina would not only take a massive human toll, but also an enormous geopolitical one.

 The Port of Southern Louisiana is the fifth-largest port in the world in terms of tonnage, and the largest port in the United States. The only global ports larger are Singapore, Rotterdam, Shanghai and Hong Kong. It is bigger than Houston, Chiba and Nagoya, Antwerp and New York/New Jersey. It is a key link in U.S. imports and exports and critical to the global economy.

 The Port of Southern Louisiana stretches up and down the Mississippi River for about 50 miles, running north and south of New Orleans from St. James to St. Charles Parish. It is the key port for the export of grains to the rest of the world -- corn, soybeans, wheat and animal feed. Midwestern farmers and global consumers depend on those exports. The United States imports crude oil, petrochemicals, steel, fertilizers and ores through the port. Fifteen percent of all U.S. exports by value go through the port. Nearly half of the exports go to Europe.

 The Port of Southern Louisiana is a river port. It depends on the navigability of the Mississippi River. The Mississippi is notorious for changing its course, and in southern Louisiana -- indeed along much of its length -- levees both protect the land from its water and maintain its course and navigability. Dredging and other maintenance are constant and necessary to maintain its navigability. It is fragile.

 If New Orleans is hit, the Port of Southern Louisiana, by definition, also will be hit. No one can predict the precise course of the storm or its consequences. However, if we speculate on worse-case scenarios the following consequences jump out:

 The port might become in whole or part unusable if levees burst. If the damage to the river and port facilities could not be repaired within 30 days when the U.S. harvests are at their peak, the effect on global agricultural prices could be substantial.

 There is a large refinery at Belle Chasse. It is the only refinery that is seriously threatened by the storm, but if it were to be inundated, 250,000 barrels per day would go off line. Moreover, the threat of environmental danger would be substantial.

 About 2 percent of world crude production and roughly 25 percent of U.S.-produced crude comes from the Gulf of Mexico and already is affected by Katrina. Platforms in the path of Katrina have been evacuated but others continue pumping. If this follows normal patterns, most production will be back on line within hours or days. However, if a Category 5 hurricane (of which there have only been three others in history) has a different effect, the damage could be longer lasting. Depending on the effect on the Port of Southern Louisiana, the ability to ship could be affected.

 A narrow, two-lane highway that handles approximately 10,000 vehicles a day, is used for transport of cargo and petroleum products and provides port access for thousands of employees is threatened with closure. A closure of as long as two weeks could rapidly push gasoline prices higher.

 At a time when oil prices are in the mid-60-dollar range and starting to hurt, the hurricane has an obvious effect. However, it must be borne in mind that the Mississippi remains a key American shipping route, particularly for the export and import of a variety of primary commodities from grain to oil, as well as steel and rubber. Andrew Jackson fought hard to keep the British from taking New Orleans because he knew it was the main artery for U.S. trade with the world. He was right and its role has not changed since then.

 This is not a prediction. We do not know the path of the storm and we cannot predict its effects. It is a warning that if a Category 5 hurricane hits the Port of Southern Louisiana and causes the damage that is merely at the outer reach of the probable, the effect on the global system will be substantial.

Update [2005-8-28 16:19:53 by Prof. Goose]:from NOLA.com: THE BIG ONE

"A catastrophic hurricane represents 10 or 15 atomic bombs in terms of the energy it releases. Think about it. New York lost two big buildings. Multiply that by 10 or 20 or 30 in the area impacted and the people lost, and we know what could happen."-Joseph Suhayda LSU Engineer

"The worst case is a hurricane moving in from due south of the city," said Suhayda, who has developed a computer simulation of the flooding from such a storm. On that track, winds on the outer edges of a huge storm system would be pushing water in Breton Sound and west of the Chandeleur Islands into the St. Bernard marshes and then Lake Pontchartrain for two days before landfall.

A variety of creatures -- rats, mice and nutria, poisonous snakes and alligators, fire ants, mosquitoes and abandoned cats and dogs -- will be searching for the same dry accommodations that people are using.

Technorati Tags: , , , .

So, will this cause absolute supply limits to consumption in the short term - it does appear that we could lose about 1-1.5m b/d of production and some refining capacity. That would mean that we would have to reduce consumption by about 5-10% to offset the impact.

There are a few policy options, none of which will be popular, but one has to be chosen or prices will spike to over $100 to destroy demand the old fashioned way - using supply and demand.

Or this could finally be the moment where politicians and government agencies begin testing ways to curb consumption in other ways - pleas to reduce personal (non-emergency) consumption. For instance in NYC the Mayor instituted a morning hours ban on single passenger cars coming into Manhattan after 9/11 as a way to ease congestion. This was eventually ended, but the regional economy did not suffer. If each state, each city, each county did a little bit to reduce consumption, we could easily reduce our daily consumption without major economic disruptions.

Then if the prices go back up again after the emergency, government leaders looking to take positive action could look back at what worked and what didn't.

But this remains a pretty optimistic (almost utopian) vision.

I think instead they will open the SPR....sorry Ianqui. :(

But this remains a pretty optimistic (almost utopian) vision.
You're right about that, Peak Guy. Don't forget the New York metropolitan area has the nation's most robust multi-modal transportation system, so people who don't want to carpool can take commuter rail, subways, buses, ferries or even bicycles. Most of the rest of the country doesn't have that luxury (and will have even less if Amtrak subsidies cease). The ban on single-occupancy vehicles had less of an impact in NYC than it would elsewhere because of its multimodalism and dense land use pattern.

I think if there's ever a reason to open the SPR, this would be it ... provided that, as expected, the SPR itself isn't clobbered by the hurricane.

That's exactly the problem. Our over-reliance on the "freedom mobile" has now become a straight-jacket for much of American. Isn't it ironic that the liberitarian ideals that contributed to the building of suburbia have created a society with so few transportation choices. Choices are freedom.

But I do think that every level of government, private corporations, local fraternal organizations, etc could find ways of cutting their consumption of gas by 5-10%.

If they don't, then prices will spike.

From a NOAA discussion.
KATRINA IS MAINTAINING A CLASSIC PRESENTATION ON SATELLITE IMAGES...AND CATEGORY 5 INTENSITY. THE CENTRAL PRESSURE MEASURED BY A NOAA HURRICANE HUNTER PLANE AT 1755Z AND 1923Z WAS 902 MB...WHICH IS THE FOURTH LOWEST ON RECORD IN THE ATLANTIC BASIN BEHIND HURRICANE GILBERT OF 1988...THE LABOR DAY HURRICANE OF 1935...AND HURRICANE ALLEN OF 1980. HAVING SAID THAT...DATA FROM THE STEPPED-FREQUENCY MICROWAVE RADIOMETER INSTRUMENT ON BOARD THE AIRCRAFT SUGGEST THAT THE SURFACE TO 700 MB FLIGHT LEVEL WIND RATIO IS NOT QUITE AS LARGE AS WE TYPICALLY USE...AND THE INITIAL INTENSITY IS ADJUSTED SLIGHTLY TO 145 KT. HURRICANES DO NOT MAINTAIN SUCH GREAT INTENSITY FOR VERY LONG. HOWEVER THERE ARE NO OBVIOUS LARGE-SCALE MECHANISMS...SUCH AS INCREASED VERTICAL SHEAR...TO WEAKEN KATRINA. THE HURRICANE IS LIKELY TO MAKE LANDFALL WITH CATEGORY 4 OR 5 INTENSITY.
Recent reports are predicting storm surges of at least 20 feet and perhaps as high as 28 feet, well above the 17 foot levee system protecting New Orleans.
Crude Oil is now $ 70.54, up $ 4.41 or 6.7%.
http://www.bloomberg.com/energy/

Rick

The latest missive from Sheikh Ahmad al-Fahd al-Sabah [Kuwait Energy Minister] OPEC concerned by high prices but insists supply sufficient
We are becoming increasingly concerned at the continuing high level of oil prices, which does not properly reflect the underlying fundamentals of the market
Hurricane? What hurricane?
what was the Iraqi disinformation minister's name again?  is he working for the Saudis now?  :)  

A-ha, found it.  Mohammed Saeed al-Sahaf, Iraqi Minister of Information

http://www.welovetheiraqiinformationminister.com/

dumb bastards don't expect that we will realize that it's really shitty oil that screws up refineries, eh?

posted up front...thanks!
If the damage arising out of the storm is at least as significant as Ivan last year we could see prices at 73 within the week once the details are known.

http://www.trendvue.com/charts/2005/08/tv20050828-02.gif
Chart: CLV5 with up and down targets

If the storm by some miracle is a non-event, we would expect price to retest the range lows near 62 - 63. That seems unlikely in the near term.

Natural gas is the real story here folks, currently up almost 20% from Friday, yes, 20%...  That's probably not sustainable, at least not until damage reports come in.

http://www.trendvue.com/charts/2005/08/tv20050828-03.gif
NGV5

What often happens on news is price sells off following - in this case there will be a cascade of "news" over the next several days -- whatever happens in tomorrows market (especially if prices retreat some) is not necessarily indicative where prices will end up once the story is fully told.

so...mw, what would you do when the market opens tomorrow?  There will be a sell-off right of everything but energy, right?  What sectors will get crushed?  retail?  tech?  (just curious...I'm not going to hold you to it.)
also, you may want to move the answer to that question and all of the market talk up to the new market thread I started about five minutes ago.  (I replicated the question there about Monday's open.)
Let's not forget the sordid role of the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers in its remodeling of the Mississippi delta, resulting in the subsequent and ongoing destruction of the vast coastal marshes that once protected Louisiana from storm surges.
I know it was only a movie but now that this storm has gone right down oil can alley, is there a new storm coming? I'm refering to the FX June, 2005 movie "Oil Storm".
I'm wondering just what will be the tipping point.