A Modest Proposal On Drinking and Driving
Posted by Glenn on December 31, 2005 - 3:25pm in The Oil Drum: Local
It is astonishing to reflect on how much the automobile has changed our physicial landscape and our culture. The legal drinking age in most countries around the world is 16 or 18, but in car-culture America it is 21. The main reason for this difference is more than just the usual American Puritanical attitudes, but rather a secular progressive movement led by groups such as Mothers Against Drunk Driving (MADD) to lower alcohol-related death rates on America's highways and byways. Prior to a 1984 Federal law linking highway funding to the 21 year drinking age (later upheld by a 1987 Supreme Court ruling) each state set it's own drinking age. Since then the law (paternalism?) has been credited with saving thousands of lives on America's highways. It has also stood up time and again to ridicule at the inconsistencies between being able to vote, join the military, smoke cigarettes, buy firearms, get married, run for political office, but not have a pint of beer at a bar.
In the spirit of balancing individual freedoms of voting age citizens and limiting the carnage on America's roads, I have a modest proposal: At age 18, new voting age citizens can obtain a 3-year licence to Either Drink OR Drive, but not both.
This would empower the youth of America to be more responsible for their choices, a youth culture that values mass transit and carpooling. This one policy change could also take tens of thousands of cars off the road.
So, how about it America? Should we continue to let the car culture drive our drinking age restrictions, or should we let individuals choose their own path? Write your thoughts to Transportation Secretary Norman Minetta at dot.comments@dot.gov (that's the part of Federal government that has threatened to withhold highway funds) and tell them to let local governments set regulations on drinking and driving that are more appropriate to their transportation situation.
When I worked in Cambridge (UK), during my early 20s, I discovered a great British institution called "the local" - every little village, town, or general gathering of anymore than 10 houses seemed to have a local pub, somewhere that anyone in the surrounding area could walk or ride a bike to conveniently. In "the local" you would find an intergenerational group of people from the area that all knew each other, drank, talked, debated, argued/fought and learned to live with each other. People even brought their kids to talk to the old men and drank soda and juice. I thought it was one of the best parts of British culture, and as a side benefit this institution greatly reduces driving to go drinking.